I experienced a challenge recently that is still on my mind. It
was yesterday, actually, and I am having some trouble processing. I had one near-fight erupt outside of my classroom in my first year
teaching high school, and another near-fight erupt inside my classroom that
same semester. In the second, the worst that happened was some desks were
overturned, as we were able to separate the two girls in question. Last year, a
fight that began in the hallway somehow barreled into my room and I ended up
watching two girls with their hands deep in the other’s hair pulling out
as much as possible for ten minutes until an administrator arrived to break it
up. Yesterday, I was amazed as a 6’4” male Spanish teacher watched as I and
another female biology teacher (close to my height) broke up a fight in his
classroom between two boys. Though he towers over everyone in his class and
clearly had the physical ability to help us bring this to an end, he literally
stood there and watched as we came between the two boys, both of us taking
missed hits and swings and trying to get past the dozen students trying to
film. The questions going through my mind were a combination of the following:
1) Why did he just stand there? Part of me knew he was hesitant
to get involved in case anyone got hurt and he would be liable, but another
part was genuinely perplexed that he was okay watching two women much smaller
than him intervene.
2) How can we get past this culture of students filming fights instead of
trying to prevent them or stop them once they start? As the biology teacher and I struggled to get this boy
out of the classroom, we were met by a WALL of at least 10 students with their
cameras who seemed much more interested in getting good footage than they did
in seeing out the wellbeing of either of their classmates. I literally stood
against the door blocking them once we managed to get in the hallway, and they
kept trying to push the door open in order to get into the hallway to get more
video.
3) What is the actual solution for this? In my four years teaching,
I have always called an administrator immediately, but with the size of my
school, it has always taken over 5 minutes for someone to arrive regardless of
whether it was a legitimate health emergency like a seizure or a fight of any
variety. I have been told to stay out of it and not put my hands on students
for liability purposes, but are we really supposed to feel comfortable watching
our students get hurt? Are we supposed to develop the same insensitivity to
fighting that our students develop?
I’m curious if any of you have experiences similar to mine, or
insight on the matter. Somehow, sitting back and calling an administrator doesn’t
cut it for me, and I know there must be better solutions in places elsewhere. In addition, once I am a leader, I don't think I will feel any more comfortable breaking up fights than I do now. I know we have all seen videos of SROs slamming kids to the ground and carrying out gross abuses of power, so I don't know if an SRO presence is truly part of a good solution here. Given that fights can be minimized but are ultimately inevitable to an extent, what are legitimately good ways to handle this?
You have expressed a valid concern. During my 11 years of teaching and now in administration, I have not had any training that involves restraining individuals during fights or anything related to conflict resolution. I believe that districts know that a problem exists, but it is one that is difficult to address. Often time teachers and administrators are so afraid to get involved. Teachers have expressed concerns with students accusing them of excessive force, getting seriously hurt, or accused of other ill-willed intentions. Honestly, I am not sure what is the right way, there is the ethical as well as the legal side. It would be more beneficial to have guidance from the district office.
ReplyDeleteValerie,
ReplyDeleteThis is a huge concern as a teacher and I completely agree with you that I could not just stand by knowing that one of my students is in a situation where he or she could get hurt. How does the administration at your school suggest you handle fights? Is there any type of school-wide behavior system like PBIS? Since it usually takes your administration more than five minutes to get there what do they expect you to do during that time? It sounds like an extremely tough situation. I understand the hesitance from the male teacher but it is also our job to keep our students safe. I work at an elementary school and have not faced a similar situation to the one you described so I am not sure how I would handle it. Thank you for sharing and I wish I had more guidance. This sounds like a difficult situation.
Although, you may not physically intervene, you can vocally intervene by telling students to stop fighting/stay away from each other/back up. As an administrator, I did not step into the middle of a fight. If I were called for a fight, I always arrived with an SRO.
ReplyDelete